With artificial intelligence dominating the hotel articling and LinkedInsphere for the past eight months of 2025, the focus in hospitality has inevitably turned towards ‘data as the new oil’: how to collect it, clean it and channel it into systems that can reveal patterns invisible to the naked eye. One of the most valuable uses for this data lies in segmentation.
In particular, it helps hoteliers confront a deceptively simple question: how do you separate guests who come back because it’s convenient from those who return because they are genuinely loyal to your brand?
At first glance, the distinction might sound trivial. After all, a repeat booking is still revenue. And ‘revenue is revenue’ as they say.
Yet when examined more closely, the motivations behind these two groups point to very different commercial strategies. A guest who rebooks because your property has the lowest price or the most convenient location cannot be counted on if those variables shift. A loyal guest, on the other hand, stays despite higher rates or a longer commute, choosing your brand because of its design, service culture, or emotional resonance. Understanding the difference shapes how a brand grows across markets, how it attracts new audiences and how it sustains long-term pricing power.
Advertisements
Recurring guests aren’t to be dismissed; they fill rooms and generate cash flow. But they operate in a transactional way, making choices largely on cost, convenience or corporate policy. They’ll defect the moment a competitor offers a better deal. Loyal customers behave differently. They perceive your hotel as an extension of themselves. They’ll tolerate rate increases, book premium rooms or advocate on your behalf because they’ve developed a relationship that goes beyond lodging. The future of profitability lies in recognizing which type of guest is sitting in your lobby.
Failing to make this distinction leaves a hotel tied to market dynamics it can’t control. When your business relies solely on recurring guests, rate strategy becomes a race to the bottom. This is where data proves transformative. Modern tools allow hoteliers to uncover the signals that hint at loyalty—booking behaviors, feedback patterns, and sentiment hidden within reviews. The more effectively you can interpret these patterns, the easier it becomes to craft pricing, promotions, and experiences that elevate you above commoditization.
Historically, hospitality executives leaned on intuition. But as Henry Ford once quipped, if he had asked people what they wanted, they would have asked for faster horses. Guests may request cheaper rooms, yet what creates lasting loyalty is often something they can’t articulate—uniqueness, design, care, or surprise. In today’s market, pursuing “faster horses” is a dead end; cultivating loyalty requires vision, creativity, and the courage to deliver experiences that people don’t even realize they’re missing until they encounter them.
Consider recurring guests as pragmatic travelers; they want efficiency. These might be road warriors who stay repeatedly because of proximity to an office or a favorable negotiated rate. They’re grateful for consistency but won’t hesitate to defect. Loyal guests are motivated by deeper currents. They choose your brand because they trust it. They resonate with its story. They feel seen when they walk through the lobby. These guests don’t merely book a bed; they invest in belonging. That sense of attachment, once nurtured, is what allows hotels to thrive independent of fluctuating market forces.
Identifying loyalty requires robust, centralized data. Look at recency, frequency and monetary value (RFM) to separate the heavy users from the high-value advocates. Track booking lead times; guests who trust your brand are often willing to commit far in advance. Pay attention to which travelers volunteer feedback and what they say about your service. Explore first-party and zero-party data to see which guests are actively sharing information with you. Each of these threads can be woven into a clearer picture of loyalty versus repetition.
The benefits of segmenting these groups ripple across the organization. Loyal customers not only accept higher rates, they book more direct, spend more on ancillary services and engage more deeply with premium offerings. They become your marketers, generating social buzz and word-of-mouth referrals. Most importantly, they provide resilience. When occupancy dips, loyal guests help sustain margins because they aren’t making decisions purely on price.
Seen this way, data isn’t just about squeezing efficiency out of operations. It’s a compass for innovation. The questions you can ask become more refined: Which new products will loyal guests adopt first? Which amenities resonate most with younger generations? What pre-arrival incentives convert OTA guests into direct bookers? Each answer provides another lever to strengthen loyalty and sharpen differentiation.
Hospitality, after all, is more than ‘lodging’. As Claus Sendlinger of Design Hotels once observed (and we’re paraphrasing but please Google the real quote), most hotels provide rooms and meals; hospitality is about genuine care. Technology now allows us to measure which guests experience that care as authentic and which do not. Segmenting between recurring and loyal customers is not about exclusion; it’s about understanding motivation. That understanding is the gateway to stronger relationships, premium pricing and the kind of enduring success that market fluctuations cannot erode.
Ultimately, the difference between a hotel that survives and one that thrives lies in how it treats data. Recurring guests provide revenue today; loyal customers ensure resilience tomorrow. The role of AI is not just to automate but to illuminate, helping hoteliers ask better questions and craft experiences that transform transactions into bonds. The year of data is not about faster horses; it’s about building a new kind of carriage altogether—one that carries loyalty at its core.
